From User |
Tweet |
AudienceDevSpec |
Welcome to #auddev chat! Today I am here with @maricarjagger events organisation and marketing professional out of Portsmouth, UK. |
AudienceDevSpec |
Hi @maricarjagger #auddev |
AudienceDevSpec |
Please use the hashtag #auddev to chat with us. |
RachealMc |
MT @audiencedevspec: Welcome to #auddev chat! I’m here with @maricarjagger events organisation & marketing profess. out of Portsmouth, UK. |
AudienceDevSpec |
The main question is: Do people differentiate going to professional vs amateur performances? #auddev |
RachealMc |
RT @audiencedevspec: Please use the hashtag #auddev to chat with us. |
AudienceDevSpec |
RT @maricarjagger: Yes. The question is whether we should differentiate between amateur and professional events through pricing. #auddev |
AudienceDevSpec |
@maricarjagger So, meaning that the price of professional should reflect a higher price? #auddev |
RachealMc |
RT @audiencedevspec: The main question is: Do people differentiate going to professional vs amateur performances? #auddev |
AudienceDevSpec |
Right now I think there is all sorts of murky blur lines happening between “professional” and “amateur”. #auddev |
THEATREtc |
RT @RachealMc: RT @audiencedevspec: The main question is: Do people differentiate going to professional vs amateur performances? #auddev |
RachealMc |
@audiencedevspec That’s recently come up here in Toronto with a vengeance. #auddev |
AudienceDevSpec |
@RachealMc Can you give me an example? #auddev |
RachealMc |
@audiencedevspec Our Actor’s Assn attempted a protest of one of our largest production companies over bringing in a non-union tour #auddev |
Silagh |
Yes, audiences do have different perceptions between professional and amateur productions. #auddev |
AudienceDevSpec |
@RachealMc Yes, the Union issue comes into play in this discussion. Were they charging the same ticket price too? #auddev |
maricarjagger |
RT @AudienceDevSpec: Please use the hashtag #auddev to chat with us. |
AudienceDevSpec |
What also gets blurry is who is to define who is professional and who is amateur. #auddev |
RachealMc |
@silagh they do have different perceptions, but the question is what classifies amateur vs. professional? #Auddev |
JessieRelephant |
RT @AudienceDevSpec: The main question is: Do people differentiate going to professional vs amateur performances? #auddev |
maricarjagger |
@AudienceDevSpec @RachealMc I didn’t event think of the Union as part of the equation! Interesting #auddev |
AudienceDevSpec |
There are companies that say they are professional, but the quality may not be. Will the audiences know the difference? #auddev |
Silagh |
Some audiences expect lots of parents with video cameras at amateur performances. Even if not kids in show. #auddev |
RachealMc |
@audiencedevspec In the US being non-union does not automatically mean amateur, but it does here and the stigma’s huge. #auddev |
RachealMc |
Absolutely. RT @maricarjagger: @AudienceDevSpec Should we price a professional show more than an amateur show? #auddev |
AudienceDevSpec |
@RachealMc Wow, so in Canada there actually is a standard based on “Union”? #auddev |
RachealMc |
@audiencedevspec 100%. #auddev |
maricarjagger |
@AudienceDevSpec @RachealMc We were discussing recently whether a ‘professional musician’ necessarily one who has a degree in music #auddev |
AudienceDevSpec |
@RachealMc The lines completely blur in the US. I have been to amateur performances in one city that are professional in others #auddev |
RachealMc |
@audiencedevspec Yes, they were charging a comparable ticket price. #auddev |
RachealMc |
@audiencedevspec It becomes trickier because it was originally a US union tour & got downgraded before it arrived here. #Auddev |
AudienceDevSpec |
@RachealMc How does one get into the Union then? Are there quality standards or just a fee to pay? #auddev |
RachealMc |
@maricarjagger @AudienceDevSpec @RachealMc some of the most gifted & skilled musicians I know don’t. #auddev |
maricarjagger |
@AudienceDevSpec @RachealMc I suppose there lies the difficulty with pricing! #auddev |
AudienceDevSpec |
Will an audience member choose a higher price ticket for the perceived extra quality? #auddev |
RachealMc |
@audiencedevspec When I lived in Miami it was like that, same for my experience in Houston. #Auddev |
AudienceDevSpec |
@maricarjagger @RachealMc I have seen the same pricing for amateur/professional. #auddev |
RachealMc |
Great question. RT @audiencedevspec: Will an audience member choose a higher price ticket for the perceived extra quality? #auddev |
AudienceDevSpec |
This also relates to grants and other funding as well. #auddev |
clydefitch |
Pivots on what “extra quality” is, no? MT @audiencedevspec: Will audiences choose higher price tickets for perceived extra quality? #auddev |
RachealMc |
@audiencedevspec It’s much easier to get into CAEA than AEA. I got in with a letter. Many ADs won’t even look at a non Eq resume. #auddev |
AudienceDevSpec |
@clydefitch So defining quality is an issue as well. #auddev |
RRCreative |
RT @AudienceDevSpec: Will an audience member choose a higher price ticket for the perceived extra quality? #auddev |
AudienceDevSpec |
@RachealMc Union is a matter of having a company claim they are professional? #auddev |
AudienceDevSpec |
I do feel a professional company has the choice of pricing higher than their local amateur company. We pay more in other industries. #auddev |
AudienceDevSpec |
It gets tricky when amateur companies price on the higher side, then the professional company may be pricing too high for audience. #auddev |
maricarjagger |
RT @AudienceDevSpec: Will an audience member choose a higher price ticket for the perceived extra quality? #auddev |
AudienceDevSpec |
I know that professional companies that I consider professional get frustrated when amateurs call themselves professional. #auddev |
AudienceDevSpec |
RT @maricarjagger: A concert by a world renowned chamber group £15 & last week a local piano teacher charges £15 for her concert. #auddev |
AudienceDevSpec |
@maricarjagger Was the chamber group upset by this? #auddev |
maricarjagger |
A concert by a world renowned chamber group is £15 here and last week a local piano teacher charges £15 for her concert. #auddev |
AudienceDevSpec |
Some Unions require an audition to get in, but some are fee based from what I am seeing/hearing. #auddev |
maricarjagger |
@AudienceDevSpec As a promoter, I was! We were careful to make sure the prices are affordable, but what is affordable? #auddev |
AudienceDevSpec |
@maricarjagger Most reports point out that $25 or under is “affordable”. People will pay more for what they want. #auddev |
AudienceDevSpec |
What is also interesting is sometimes the amateur groups get more of an audience than the professional ones. #auddev |
RachealMc |
MT @maricarjagger: @AudienceDevSpec …We were careful to make sure the prices are affordable, but what is affordable? #auddev |
AudienceDevSpec |
@clydefitch An amateur group can have a star show up too. #auddev |
clydefitch |
@audiencedevspec Also, wouldn’t you agree “extra value” varies (or differs) by genre, setting, time of year, magnitude? #auddev |
maricarjagger |
@AudienceDevSpec That begs the question whether less people will want it if the event is more expensive? #auddev |
RachealMc |
@audiencedevspec @maricarjagger That is a key question. #auddev |
RachealMc |
@maricarjagger @AudienceDevSpec I’ve worked with companies where the gross over spending & wastage is sickening. #auddev |
AudienceDevSpec |
@maricarjagger That is a major question to consider. People will spend money on what they value. #auddev |
AudienceDevSpec |
I think it is about asking your audience for their perceptions before you price. What is worth it to them? #auddev |
RachealMc |
@maricarjagger @AudienceDevSpec The costs are then passed on to the audience & they wonder why people complain of high prices. #auddev |
AudienceDevSpec |
@RachealMc @maricarjagger So some professional companies don’t have to price as high if not wasteful. Good point! #auddev |
maricarjagger |
@AudienceDevSpec I’m sure they will value something they know well and that means ‘touring’ artists cannot win #auddev |
AudienceDevSpec |
@maricarjagger Great point, which is why #auddev is so important so they get to know! |
maricarjagger |
In the case of the local pianist I do realise there’s an element of ‘who you know’ determining attendance. #auddev |
RachealMc |
@audiencedevspec @RachealMc @maricarjagger I think we all need to be realistic about the economy & spending patterns. #auddev |
AudienceDevSpec |
So the audience needs to perceive as valuable to them and see the value in the extra cost of the ticket. #auddev |
AudienceDevSpec |
I do wish there were more standards for “professional” “amateur”. Being subjective, it may never happen. #auddev |
maricarjagger |
@AudienceDevSpec Are we saying that cultural offering need some longevity to afford time for audience development? #auddev |
AudienceDevSpec |
@maricarjagger I’m not sure I completely understand your question. #auddev |
AudienceDevSpec |
Join us for #auddev chat! |
maricarjagger |
@AudienceDevSpec Audience development needs time, right? #auddev |
dloehr |
@AudienceDevSpec The reason my theatre co. uses “professional” is simply to distinguish between hobby & vocation. We also tour. #auddev |
AudienceDevSpec |
@melissaimpact Interesting, so now we have more labels in the mix. LOL! #auddev |
RachealMc |
RT @audiencedevspec: I do wish there were more standards for “professional” “amateur”. Being subjective, it may never happen. #auddev |
AudienceDevSpec |
@dloehr Do we have a list to define professional vs. amateur though. Couldn’t an amateur company tour. If they get a little pay…#auddev |
melissaimpact |
@AudienceDevSpec While not a fan of over-labeling, I think this one fills a definite need & eliminates some confusion. #auddev |
AudienceDevSpec |
I see some professional companies say they are community oriented, which also gets a little tricky. #auddev |
maricarjagger |
@AudienceDevSpec @dloehr So your definition is if this is your job (not hobby) then you are a professional? #auddev |
AudienceDevSpec |
@melissaimpact Semi-pro is a label in the music world that is similar. #auddev |
dloehr |
@AudienceDevSpec We tour outside of the region, though. Our community group is largely shop owners, people with day jobs… #auddev |
melissaimpact |
@AudienceDevSpec The trickiness lies in the polyvalence of the word “community,” here used in a diff way than “community thtr” #auddev |
AudienceDevSpec |
@maricarjagger @dloehr Right now, people piece together their income, so if they are paid, could be one of their jobs. #auddev |
dloehr |
@AudienceDevSpec …who can’t afford to take the time away from those jobs. #auddev |
RachealMc |
RT @dloehr: @AudienceDevSpec The reason my theatre co. uses “professional” is simply to distinguish between hobby & vocation… #auddev |
melissaimpact |
@dloehr @AudienceDevSpec Other issue is that many working at small thtrs of our own for no/low pay are pros working at larger thtrs #auddev |
AudienceDevSpec |
MT @clydefitch: Often I feel amateur vs. professional = issue for professionals, not amateurs. #auddev |
AudienceDevSpec |
@clydefitch Really great point! #auddev |
dloehr |
@AudienceDevSpec But we try to work with them whenever possible; there’s no class warfare here, just different goals. #auddev |
AudienceDevSpec |
@dloehr I know professionals that can’t afford it either. LOL! #auddev |
melissaimpact |
@dloehr @AudienceDevSpec “Amateur” and “professional” are inaccurate when tied only to pay grade in the arts #auddev |
AudienceDevSpec |
Here’s a monkey wrench, a professional could (and does sometimes) work for an “amateur” company. #auddev |
dloehr |
@AudienceDevSpec @maricarjagger I’m only talking about my town’s community group in terms of touring, btw. #auddev |
AudienceDevSpec |
@clydefitch You can use the #auddev hashtag. You have great points for everyone! |
dloehr |
@melissaimpact @AudienceDevSpec Right. #auddev |
maricarjagger |
@AudienceDevSpec @clydefitch It’s money and income, it’s close to everyone’s heart! #auddev |
RachealMc |
RT @melissaimpact: @dloehr @AudienceDevSpec “Amateur” and “professional” are inaccurate when tied only to pay grade in the arts #auddev |
AudienceDevSpec |
RT @clydefitch Also, what defines amateur/professional? Most professional actors don’t live off their work but never ID as amateur. #auddev |
maricarjagger |
@AudienceDevSpec @clydefitch If you trained for years and pay lots of money for college, do you want to earn less that the hobbyist? #auddev |
AudienceDevSpec |
There are some groups in my town that claim to be pro, but quality wise, they really are not in MHO. #auddev |
dloehr |
@melissaimpact @AudienceDevSpec Tho I didn’t–and don’t–use the term “amateur.” #auddev |
maricarjagger |
@AudienceDevSpec I this case I have no quibble with them if they charge less for tix #auddev |
AudienceDevSpec |
I think it is some of our perception that amateur are “stealing away” from professional that is the basis. Am I right? #auddev |
melissaimpact |
@AudienceDevSpec Not sure you can tie “professional” to quality-All it covers is whether this is your career as opposed to a hobby #auddev |
AudienceDevSpec |
@maricarjagger We would need to first establish who is pro and am and then figure out pricing as an industry. #auddev |
RachealMc |
@audiencedevspec as “Guest Artists” I would say almost all performers have done it here. #auddev |
clydefitch |
@maricarjagger @AudienceDevSpec Obviously not. I’m not celebrating the amateur vs. professional divide, I’m acknowledging it exists. #auddev |
AudienceDevSpec |
@melissaimpact However, there are “amateurs” that can produce professional work. #auddev |
melissaimpact |
@dloehr @AudienceDevSpec Me neither–I think most thtr pros do not. It’s “professional,” “professionally-oriented,” and “community” #auddev |
RachealMc |
@maricarjagger @AudienceDevSpec @clydefitch When I interviewed Brian Dennehy, he said theatre school was… #auddev |
AudienceDevSpec |
@melissaimpact I have performed in some “community” groups that were as good if not better than “professional” #auddev |
maricarjagger |
@AudienceDevSpec and that is difficult to establish and also regulate #auddev |
AudienceDevSpec |
@melissaimpact Don’t they deserve to charge more then? #auddev |
dloehr |
@melissaimpact @AudienceDevSpec Yup. #auddev |
RachealMc |
@maricarjagger @AudienceDevSpec @clydefitch … the absolute worst thing an actor could do. #Auddev |
AudienceDevSpec |
@melissaimpact Oh I agree about the label, but they could charge more because they are awesome! ;O) #auddev |
maricarjagger |
@RachealMc @AudienceDevSpec @clydefitch In a sense you’re right, going to school doesn’t prove you have talents…#auddev |
AudienceDevSpec |
@melissaimpact We were talking about ticket pricing in all this as well though. #auddev |
melissaimpact |
@AudienceDevSpec Pricing isn’t just abt quality or value–often we price low b/c we’re trying to remain accessible. #auddev |
AudienceDevSpec |
@RachealMc So the price of that “guest artist” ticket for the amateur group would go up. #auddev |
melissaimpact |
@AudienceDevSpec Pricing is about accessibility more than quality for most of us, I think #auddev |
AudienceDevSpec |
RT @melissaimpact: @AudienceDevSpec Pricing is about accessibility more than quality for most of us, I think #auddev |
melissaimpact |
@AudienceDevSpec Big pro thtrs make a minority of income as earned, majority as contributed #auddev |
RaymondMcNeel |
@clydefitch @AudienceDevSpec Per the Latin, an amateur does something for “the love”. (Oh, and Charlie Sheen is a professional.) #auddev |
RachealMc |
@audiencedevspec generally, the prices would be the same. The company would budget for the extra costs. #auddev |
AudienceDevSpec |
@maricarjagger @melissaimpact So true! But then, this could make the ticket price equal to the amateur price. #auddev |
maricarjagger |
@melissaimpact @AudienceDevSpec Our prof concerts are accessible by ticket price, but not covering the full cost of the musicians #auddev |
melissaimpact |
@AudienceDevSpec @maricarjagger Pricing more abt marketing than abt income for nonprofit thtrs–majority of their $ is contributed #auddev |
AudienceDevSpec |
@clydefitch @rachealmc @maricarjagger Plus, amateur companies can be non-profit too. #auddev |
melissaimpact |
@maricarjagger @AudienceDevSpec That’s the case for almost every 501c3 arts org in the country. High price isn’t a marker of quality #auddev |
melissaimpact |
@maricarjagger @AudienceDevSpec Low price isn’t marker of amateur. Big co.s use a plethora of price pts, some very low for outreach #auddev |
RachealMc |
@audiencedevspec @clydefitch @maricarjagger As can professional companies up here. #auddev |
melissaimpact |
@AudienceDevSpec @maricarjagger Big LORTs use lprice pts equal to smaller co.s as part of various outreach efforts all the time #auddev |
AudienceDevSpec |
@melissaimpact @maricarjagger So if the price isn’t an indication, which we have established, will the audience get it? LOL! #auddev |
melissaimpact |
@AudienceDevSpec @maricarjagger Will they get what? #auddev |
AudienceDevSpec |
@melissaimpact @maricarjagger The price is the same for both pro and ama. So, will they understand who is who? #auddev |
clydefitch |
@rachealmc @AudienceDevSpec @maricarjagger Curiously, it’s theatre that forever thrashes these issues. Er, amateur folk art, anyone? #auddev |
AudienceDevSpec |
@melissaimpact @maricarjagger We may not see price as a distinguishing value, but our audiences might. #auddev |
melissaimpact |
@AudienceDevSpec @maricarjagger I think that’s true to a certain extent, depending on the marketing & culture of the producing org #auddev |
RachealMc |
RT @audiencedevspec: @melissaimpact @maricarjagger We may not see price as a distinguishing value, but our audiences might. #auddev |
melissaimpact |
@AudienceDevSpec @maricarjagger Big co.s offer luxury exp at high price pt- better seats, etc– outreach at lower price pts. I think #auddev |
Becca_E_Smith |
@RaymondMcNeel @clydefitch @AudienceDevSpec love that, but what abt pros? Is a pro in it for the $ or just some1 who gets paid? #auddev |
melissaimpact |
@AudienceDevSpec @maricarjagger the marketing of the experience is key. Are you there for a luxury exp? Or are you there to #auddev |
AudienceDevSpec |
@Becca_E_Smith @RaymondMcNeel @clydefitch That’s a new kettle of fish there! #auddev |
maricarjagger |
@AudienceDevSpec @clydefitch @rachealmc Ego aside I think the important issue here is whether a pro can compete in the marketplace #auddev |
clydefitch |
@audiencedevspec @RachealMc @maricarjagger No more than boiling complex, nuanced socioeconomic trends to 140-word tweets. #auddev |
RachealMc |
@audiencedevspec @clydefitch @maricarjagger @clydefitch I think ego plays in any industry. #auddev |
AudienceDevSpec |
@maricarjagger I think you just rang the ding, ding, ding bell with that one! #auddev |
melissaimpact |
@AudienceDevSpec @maricarjagger see something cool you can share w/friends? The same big co can offer varying experiences #auddev |
clydefitch |
@audiencedevspec @RachealMc @maricarjagger More seriously, for some it’s totally tied to ego. Others don’t fret about labels. #auddev |
melissaimpact |
@AudienceDevSpec @maricarjagger A GREAT example of this kind of varied experience/varied price point is @berkeleyrep #auddev |
melissaimpact |
@AudienceDevSpec @maricarjagger This convo is so interesting, but I have to go teach! Loathe to leave you brilliant ppl. Thank you! #auddev |
AudienceDevSpec |
I think @clydefitch is right. All labels aside, it is going to come down to what is great & what is good. #auddev |
clydefitch |
@becca_e_smith @RaymondMcNeel @AudienceDevSpec I don’t think pro = monolithic mindset. Tho most people don’t turn down $, generally. #auddev |
AudienceDevSpec |
It’s been a quick, intense and interesting hour at #auddev chat. |
AudienceDevSpec |
Thank you to: @clydefitch @melissaimpact @RachealMc @maricarjagger @Becca_E_Smith @RaymondMcNeel @dloehr for stopping by! #auddev |
maricarjagger |
@melissaimpact We can reconvene the conversation another time with @AudienceDevSpec #auddev |
AudienceDevSpec |
Feel free to keep chatting at #auddev |
AudienceDevSpec |
I will have a transcript of this conversation on my blog Monday morning. #auddev |
maricarjagger |
@AudienceDevSpec @clydefitch @melissaimpact @RachealMc @Becca_E_Smith @RaymondMcNeel @dloehr Thank you all for the eye-opener on #auddev |
maricarjagger |
@AudienceDevSpec Thanks for hosting! #auddev |
Becca_E_Smith |
@AudienceDevSpec thanks for hosting! #auddev |
AudienceDevSpec |
We know that professional and amateur are clearly challenging to define. Price is not the indicative factor either. #auddev |
AudienceDevSpec |
What will ring true is not the labels, but the quality of the work. Everything else is merely technicality in MHO. #auddev ;O) |
RachealMc |
@audiencedevspec @clydefitch @melissaimpact @RachealMc @maricarjagger @Becca_E_Smith @RaymondMcNeel @dloehr Thank you all! #auddev |
AudienceDevSpec |
Whew! That was a fantastic conversation. We now return to our normal #auddev hashtag. |
AudienceDevSpec |
.@maricarjagger Thank you for the topic! #auddev |
AudienceDevSpec |
If you have a topic for #auddev chat, please contact me. |
clydefitch |
Thanks to: @AudienceDevSpec @melissaimpact @RachealMc @maricarjagger @Becca_E_Smith @RaymondMcNeel #auddev #FF |
maricarjagger |
@AudienceDevSpec Fascinating subject and I look forward to more #auddev sessions |